top of page

Medical Abortion vs. Surgical Abortion: Which Is Right for Me?


When faced with an unplanned pregnancy, deciding on the best course of action can feel overwhelming. In Canada, individuals have access to safe and legal abortion services, including both medical and surgical options. Understanding the differences between these methods and evaluating which one might be right for you is an important step.


What is a Medical Abortion?

Medical abortion, often referred to as "the abortion pill," involves taking medications to end a pregnancy. In Canada, this option is available up to the ninth week of pregnancy. The process usually involves two types of medication:


  1. Mifepristone: This medication blocks the hormone progesterone, which is necessary for pregnancy to continue.

  2. Misoprostol: Taken 24 to 48 hours after mifepristone, misoprostol causes the uterus to contract and expel the pregnancy.


Pros:

  • Privacy: Can be completed in the privacy of your own home.

  • Less invasive: No surgery or anesthesia is required.

  • Control: Some people prefer this method because it may feel more natural, like a miscarriage.


Cons:

  • Duration: The process can take a few days and may require more follow-up appointments.

  • Pain and bleeding: Can be heavy and more prolonged than with a surgical abortion.

  • Effectiveness: While highly effective, there is a small chance that the abortion may not be complete, requiring a surgical procedure.  After approximately 6-7 weeks’ into your pregnancy, a surgical abortion is less likely to fail than a pill abortion.  After approximately 10 weeks into your pregnancy, a surgical abortion in much more effective, safe and comfortable and is therefore recommended over the abortion pill.


What is a Surgical Abortion?

Surgical abortion is a procedure performed in a clinic or hospital setting and can be done up to 20 weeks of gestation or later, depending on provincial regulations and services. The most common type of surgical abortion is called vacuum aspiration, which is typically performed in the first trimester. Here at Cabbagetown Women’s Clinic, we provide surgical abortions up to 24 weeks' gestation.


Pros:

  • Quickness: The procedure usually takes less than 15 minutes.  (Preparing for the procedure can involve multiple days in the second trimester)

  • Effectiveness: Surgical abortion is highly effective with a success rate close to 100%.

  • One-step process: Once the procedure is done, no additional medication is typically necessary.


Cons:

  • Invasiveness: Requires a medical procedure performed at a clinic or hospital.

  • Anesthesia: May require local anesthesia, plus either general anesthesia or conscious sedation (depending on the setting of the clinic).

  • Recovery: Some may experience cramps and light bleeding for a few weeks post-procedure, but recovery is usually quick.


Considerations for Choosing the Right Option

Choosing between a medical and surgical abortion involves considering several factors:


  • Gestational Age: Medical abortions are an option in the early weeks of pregnancy.

  • Health History: Certain medical conditions may make one option safer than another.

  • Access to Care: Depending on where you live, access to one type of abortion might be easier.

  • Personal Preference: Comfort with the procedure, desire for privacy, and personal health considerations all play roles.


Conclusion

Both medical and surgical abortions are safe, effective options, but the right choice depends on individual circumstances and preferences. At Cabbagetown Women’s Clinic, we provide confidential consultations to help you understand your options and make the decision that is best for you. Remember, you are not alone, and we are here to support you every step of the way.

Comments


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page